By Steve Andrews and Randy Udall – American Society for Peak Oil
On April 13, Reuters reported the following from Riyadh:
Saudi Arabia’s King Abdullah said he had ordered some new oil discoveries left untapped to preserve oil wealth in the world’s top exporter for future generationsâ€¦
“When there were some new finds, I told them, ‘no, leave it in the ground, with grace from god, our children need it’,” King Abdullah saidâ€¦
Saudi production capacity stands at around 11.3 million bpd, and is scheduled to rise to 12.5 million bpd next year.
The Kingâ€™s remarks seem to confirm a statement made last year by Saudi oil minister Ali al-Naimi who, when asked â€œHow high can your production go?â€ replied, â€œWeâ€™ll get to 12.5 million barrels a day and then weâ€™ll see.â€
If the Saudi announcement was a bombshell, American nearly newspapers ignored it. We decided to canvass experts we respect to see what they thought. Excerpts follow:
Tom Petrie, vice president, Merrill Lynch:
â€œKing Abdullahâ€™s quote speaks to the fast-emerging reality of what I call â€˜practical peak oil.â€™ The Saudis and other exporters are placing a new emphasis on elongating the petroleum exploitation and depletion cycle. This stems from a growing awareness of the challenges of conventional resource maturity, as well as rising resource nationalism. This is likely to result in an earlier occurrence of global peak oil output than many consumers yet recognize.â€
Charles T. Maxwell, senior energy analyst, Weeden & Co:
â€œIf Saudi Arabiaâ€™s oil reserves are not going to be made available to the world in future years, beyond the expansion they have already signaled (to 12.5 million barrels/day), then the geologic oil supply constraints that we are feeling in many other parts of the world are going to close in on us earlier and more severely than we previously thought. Itâ€™s a major change in policy. Itâ€™s a powerful message. It makes the geologic message that much more decisive.â€
Chris Skrebowski, editor of Petroleum Review:
â€œKing Abdullahâ€™s statement represents the final seal of approval on an emerging Saudi policy of restricting output to save oil for future generations. In recent years the Saudis have been managing expectations of future capacity steadily downwards. No one now talks of their reaching 15mn b/d. If they reach 12.5mn b/d, while maintaining 1-2mn b/d of â€˜spareâ€™ capacity, we should plan for Saudi production to be 9-11mn b/d for the foreseeable future.
â€œHigh oil prices and bulging treasuries are giving producing countries the option of maximizing plateau production. We may never know if these decisions are being dictated by geology or driven by a political imperative of â€˜saving oil for later generations.â€™ I suspect itâ€™s a mixture of the two.
â€œIn any case, there is now a broad-based move by energy exporters, including Russia, Angola, Azerbaijan, and Norway, to restrict expansion to maximize plateau flows. If this takes hold, then global supplies will reach a peak rather earlier than analysis of future projects would indicate.â€
Matt Simmons, chairman of Simmons & Co. International:
â€œThis statement by the Supreme Ruler of Saudi Arabia has far-reaching implications. That King Addullah would now instruct his servants to conserve the oil they pump and save some for the kids and grandkids of today’s Saudi citizens is most profound.
â€œKing Abdullah has exhibited a sense of wisdom not seen since his brother, King Faisal ruled the Kingdom until his tragic assassination. Assuming his health continues, he might lead Saudi Arabia successfully into a post-peak world and create sustainable middle class wealth for the 90% of Saudi Arabia who had accidentally been left behind.
â€œThe world should bless this intelligent pronouncement. It is a reflection that Twilight set in on the oilfields of Arabia a few years ago.â€
Richard Nehring, president of Nerhingdatabase.com
â€œThis development is part of what Iâ€™ve called the â€˜Prudential Plateau.â€™ Some key countries with large reserves and resources have decided to maintain production at current levelsâ€”but not increase it. This is a two-edged sword: you can no longer count on these countries for increases, but you can count on them for the base. The United Arab Emirates and Qatar will probably join in this shift.â€
Jeffrey Rubin, chief economist, CIBC World markets
â€œA far more plausible explanation for faltering growth in Saudi production and exports is that they are rapidly approaching maximum production. Given soaring rates of internal consumption for oil, they will soon be exporting less not more crude to world oil markets.
â€œRussian Natural Resource Minister Yuri Trutnevâ€™s has said that Russian production and exports will fall this year, for the first time in a decade. We forecast that exports from OPEC, Russia and Mexico will actually decline by 2.5 million barrels per day between now and 2012. Itâ€™s far from obvious who is going to fill this supply gap, let alone meet the need of future global crude demand growth.â€
Jeremy Gilbert, BPâ€™s retired chief petroleum engineer
â€œI have no idea whether there was a real choice for the Saudis to make. Perhaps it’s all ‘spin’; perhaps there were discoveries, but there was some property of the reservoirs which made them very difficult to develop, and it made sense to delay development until improved technology or much higher prices arrived; perhaps it’s the plain basic truth – a very rare commodity.
â€œWhat I do know is that several countries in the Gulf have long chosen to operate their fields with depletion rates far below those that a Western company would consider optimal, or even sensible. Depletion rates of between 1 and 2%/ per year are not uncommon in the United Arab Emirates. Local leaders have repeatedly said that they feel an obligation to preserve some of their natural resources. These feelings must be intensified when their recent production has been sold for US dollars which have depreciated by 25% or more against other strong world currencies over the last four years.
â€œThe countries around the Gulf, which would once have come to the aid of a faltering U.S., now are either delighted about the U.S. plight or just don’t care. They are not going to do anything to reduce world oil prices. Instead, they are going to maximize their economic take while minimizing depletion of their sole natural resource.â€
Herman Franssen, president of International Energy Associates
â€œKing Abdullah’s remarks reflect the new thinking in the Middle East, where the Kuwaiti parliament has also expressed a need to stabilize oil exports. Higher oil prices enable producers to focus more on domestic investments than on increasing exports. All Gulf countries have seen huge growth in domestic demand for power and fuel. By 2015, Iran may consume as much of its crude oil as they export. The Kingâ€™s remarks mean that we in the industrialized countries better start looking for other solutions.â€
Steve Andrews and Randy Udall are two of the five co-founders of ASPO-USA.