Enclosing the commons

We hang the man and flog the woman
Who steals the goose from off the common
Yet we let the greater criminal loose
Who steals the commons from the goose

The community garden to be bulldozed

A bush turkey races through the community garden at 1 Dudley St

The fight by the rich to take the common assets of the people and control them for personal gain is as old as money itself.

High profile examples in Australia include the gift to Rupert Murdoch’s Fox Corporation of the Sydney Showgrounds. Clive Palmer’s current request to turn the Bimblebox Nature Reserve into the vast China First coal mine represents a similar challenge in our own time.

Not all examples of the encroachment of private ownership onto public land are so visible, though. The alienation of the public from riverbanks, for example, happens gradually and steadily. What is, in law, a public asset becomes inaccessible and enjoyable only to a few.

The recent victory by Gully Watch over an attempt to have the river end of Sankey St closed and passed into private title is one victory against this general encroachment. Well done to the team that fought that battle and to Helen Abrahams who lobbied so effectively on behalf of the residents.

In some cases, private owners simply want to keep the public away from public land near their property so that they can enjoy exclusive access to the natural assets which they believe that they should have privileged access to.

This certainly seems to be the case at the end of Boundary St where some “unallocated public land” (read The Commons) is to be closed off because of complaints by neighbours that it was being enjoyed by the public.

Part of the community garden to be destroyed

Part of the community garden to be destroyed

Newman forbid!

Disclosure of interest: I am the publisher of Westender and a resident of Riviera Apartments at 5 Dudley St (known to the locals as Rancho Relaxo)

Westender is interested to explore community views and the legal basis of this enclosure. Obviously we all want to ensure that the public have access to a public asset. The question appears to be is that best served by having it open, or closed?

We welcome your views and expertise.

Here is the letter I sent to my neighbours asking for their support.

Hello neighbour,

In addition to our citizenship, our humanity and many hopes and fears, you and I share the commonwealth of this nation. Some of this is managed and provided by the government – roads, running water, well managed parks, sewage, fire and police services. Many things, though, are simply ours to enjoy: the sea, the air, the river that runs past our homes. This common wealth is part of the environment that nurtures and supports us. We must cooperate to preserve these common assets.

There are two blocks of land, known officially as no.s 1 and 3 Dudley St which are part of this common wealth and that you and I, as neighbours, share.

  • Some of us have used this space to develop a community garden so that all of us might enjoy shade, free food and access to heirloom seeds.
  • Some of us have used this space to park our cars.
  • Twice in the last six months, ex-residents of number 5 Dudley St have used this space to celebrate a 21st birthday and a graduation.

Apparently these uses of the common land have offended some of you.

  • Someone has been pulling plants out of the community garden.
  • Someone else has registered an official complaint and caused the land to be locked up so that it will be no longer commonly accessible.

This makes us a poorer community.

There are many things that neighbours may not like about each other.

  • Renovations that wake us all every morning at 6:30am for 6 months
  • The Labrador that poos every day in the most inappropriate places.
  • Fertile tom cats that spray, fight and kill wildlife
  • The boat shed wedding parties that broadcast bad music

Unpleasant as these things are, we take them in our stride as part of the awkwardness of being members of the human family. We respect each other’s right to be annoying. More bureaucracy controlling more aspects of our daily lives does not help us get along.

I will be fighting this closure of the commons. I invite you to join me in maintaining this public asset and working together to make it wonderful.

Geoff Ebbs.

One Comment

  1. Anony mous 13 September, 2013

Leave a Reply